'Growing increasingly fearful': Italy's Gaza Demonstrations Raise Political Strain on Meloni

A piercing sound of blaring horns and port employees shouting “you are not welcome” welcomed an Israel-linked cargo vessel when it docked in the Tuscan port city this week.

For 48 hours, the striking port laborers stood their ground, refusing to handle the ship’s cargo in a act of defiant solidarity for the people of Gaza and the international aid convoy attempting to deliver humanitarian assistance to the besieged territory. The protest was a triumph and the vessel, headed to the US and Canada, left the port.

Nationwide Port Actions Spread

From Genoa, Trieste and Ravenna in the northern region, to southern harbors in the south, in recent weeks port workers throughout the country have succeeded in obstructing vessels believed to be transporting arms for Israel, as resistance to the country’s war in the Gaza Strip intensifies.

The workers’ resolve to prevent arms shipments and disrupt commerce has been a key element of the pro-Palestinian uprising in the nation as pressure mounts on Prime Minister Meloni’s far-right government to take a stronger stance against Israel.

“The Israeli military is conducting an extermination of civilians in the Gaza Strip – by taking lives, by starving them,” said a dockworker, Luca Simoni. “We must not stay silent. We have always been a harbor of refuge, not one of war. We will continue protesting until this war concludes.”

National Walkout Adds Pressure

On the end of the week, thousands took to the streets after Cgil organized the second general strike in under 14 days, shutting educational institutions, stalling traffic and causing disruption on public transport and in medical services. There were also spontaneous protests on Wednesday night after Israeli forces stopped the aid convoy and arrested numerous participants, including the well-known activist the environmental advocate.

The incident in Livorno was the first time an vessel from Israel transporting commercial goods had been prevented from docking.

Public Opinion and Government Reaction

Latest polls show significant support among the public – including a substantial share of voters of Meloni’s ruling coalition – for the establishment of a Palestinian state and in favor of the flotilla aid mission.

Meloni has spoken against Israel’s killing of Palestinian people in the past few months, casting it as a “excessive” response to the militant group’s assault, and has opened up to the country recognizing a Palestinian state, albeit with caveats. But she continues trying to walk a fine line between being one of the strongest supporters of Israel in the EU and a ally of Arab nations, all the while aligning with the policies of the American leader, Donald Trump.

Still, she is mindful of public opinion, especially with Italy in the midst of several regional elections, and has sought to exploit the protests and flotilla to criticize her political rivals.

The Prime Minister has characterized the flotilla as “dangerous and irresponsible” and, despite the aid effort involving hundreds of activists from different countries, she said it was only targeted at “creating problems” for her government. She criticized the national walkout, accusing Italians of undertaking “a long weekend masquerading as a political uprising” while claiming the event was politically orchestrated and offered no real benefit to the people of Gaza.

“The Meloni government can only survive with someone to blame,” stated Gianfranco Francese, who leads the Livorno unit of the major trade union. “There is also a great contradiction between what Meloni claims and what she implements,” he continued. “She speaks of being a great patriot, a religious person and a mother, but she has not taken any political or diplomatic action to halt the killing of women and children.”

Political Stability Amid Unrest

But despite the strong public sentiment shown through the series of solidarity demonstrations, the ruling party continues to lead in surveys, at approximately thirty percent, and she has headed an unusually steady Italian government since taking office in October 2022.

“From one perspective, there is the larger part of public opinion in solidarity with Palestinians which wants an end to the war,” explained a political analyst, a co-founder of a polling firm. “But you won’t observe the effects of this when it comes to vote.”

Pregliasco referred to last week’s elections in the central area where Meloni’s coalition won a another term. The similar result is expected in votes in Veneto and Calabria.

He said there was “a real risk of the [Gaza] movement having too much of a leftwing identity, which would alienate people who are appalled with the war but who are not active supporters”.

Expert Perspectives

Nadia Urbinati at New York’s Columbia University and the University of Bologna, said the explanation why the consequences of the protests were not being reflected in elections was because barely half of Italian voters participate in elections.

“And the ones who vote, vote for the right,” she added, noting that the Prime Minister could readily use the unrest to disarm opponents.

She said every spontaneous movement of the public was susceptible to being infiltrated by opposing groups, and alleged that this had been occurring in order to “criminalise and repress” the solidarity campaign.

Medical Professionals Participate

A cardiologist in the capital, has attended multiple demonstrations in the Italian capital and participated in the protest near a central square on Friday.

“Last night, there was an initiative held in medical facilities during which we remembered the thousands of medics killed in the conflict zone while providing aid,” she said. “It was a deeply emotional occasion and we will continue to mobilise. You may not observe it in political polls yet, but I believe this government is becoming very afraid of us.”
Teresa Greene
Teresa Greene

Travel enthusiast and local expert sharing insights on the best places to stay and visit in Bari and beyond.